Replies to This Discussion

ModPermalink Reply by It's Me, Sadie Skeletol on January 16, 2011 at 11:45am

I think there won't be a Melody Carver doll because I think they hired the author and said you must use these characters as monsters:

 

Frankie Stein

Draculaura

Clawdeen Wolf

Lagoona Blue

Cleo de Nile

Deuce Gorgon

Jackson Jekyll

DJ Hyde (I'm guess before he was a doll he was originally DJ not Holt)

Clawd Wolf

Heath Burns (he's in the book but he's not known as a monster to us yet)

and a bunch of others

 

And then gave her complete freedom to do whatever she wanted which includes Melody Carver. She was the author's idea not Mattel's. I do like the books, but the dolls and the book are two different universes.

Permalink Reply by Felica Fright on January 16, 2011 at 12:27pm

Ditto

ModPermalink Reply by It's Me, Sadie Skeletol on January 16, 2011 at 12:31pm

With who me or lilibit800?

Felica Fright said:

Ditto

Permalink Reply by Felica Fright on January 16, 2011 at 12:32pm

you

Sadie Skeleton said:

With who me or lilibit800?

Felica Fright said:

Ditto

ModPermalink Reply by It's Me, Sadie Skeletol on January 16, 2011 at 12:32pm

okay

Felica Fright said:

you

Sadie Skeleton said:

With who me or lilibit800?

Felica Fright said:

Ditto

Permalink Reply by lilibit008 on January 16, 2011 at 12:43pm

I don't know, I still kind of feel like the concept for the book would have had to at least been accepted by Mattel before Lisi Harrison was allowed to write it, you know? It's just weird to me that they deviate so much between the book, the dolls, and the webisodes. It really is how you said, they're like completely different universes that just happen to have some of the same characters. I still like everything, I just wish that there was a little more consistency. Now we have conflicting story lines, character mix-ups, and stuff like that. Like I think the Holt/DJ thing might even be the result of some kind of miscommunication. Unless he is called "DJ" in the book because he likes to DJ. And Heath Burns in the webisodes seems very similar to Holt's doll, minus the blue skin.

Permalink Reply by Sammy on January 16, 2011 at 1:07pm

I'm not sure about Jackson being a normie technically. He just doesn't know he's a monster.

 

Mattel probably got the doll line sorted, hired Lisi, said "These are your characters." and then she wandered off and did her own thing with them causing much headaches for Mattels development team.

I'd take the cartoon as canon and the book as non-canon. Melody Carver sounds quite monstery. In my mind, she'd be the daughter of Sweeny Todd. (Not a monster, but a brilliant horror character. Specially when played by Johnny Depp...)

ModPermalink Reply by It's Me, Sadie Skeletol on January 16, 2011 at 1:16pm

That would be so awesome Melody being the daughter of Sweeny Todd.

Sammy said:

I'm not sure about Jackson being a normie technically. He just doesn't know he's a monster.

 

Mattel probably got the doll line sorted, hired Lisi, said "These are your characters." and then she wandered off and did her own thing with them causing much headaches for Mattels development team.

I'd take the cartoon as canon and the book as non-canon. Melody Carver sounds quite monstery. In my mind, she'd be the daughter of Sweeny Todd. (Not a monster, but a brilliant horror character. Specially when played by Johnny Depp...)

ModPermalink Reply by It's Me, Sadie Skeletol on January 16, 2011 at 9:06pm

Well since the next book will have chapters about Cleo there's hope.

 
iLoveGhoulia said:

My only problem with the book was that Ghoulia wasn't in it!

Permalink Reply by RaDioAcTiVe BuNNy on January 16, 2011 at 9:27pm

Multi universes are just a fact of life in a fandom like monster high. Its the same way wif my love of Transformers. Between the multitude of different cartoons, there is the marvel comics, Dreamwave comics,and IDW comics adaptations. It would be nice if they stuck to one an ran with it, but it never will.

Permalink Reply by Sunnie Bunny on January 17, 2011 at 12:21am

I read/Listen to the book and it was AWESOME!

I too cant wait till the next one comes out to find out what happens next.

 

In regards to Melody Carver lilibit008 I thinks she feels that she "WAS or IS" because she didn't fit in h...

 

We have to remember Mattel Bought the rights to the Characters in the Book so the show we see on youtube and the book have nothing to do with each other really.

 

IN the book Monsters Hide and in the cartoon they go to a School FOR Monsters.

Basically Mattel Taking the rights to a book and making it a big Money Making Franchise.

Permalink Reply by lilibit008 on January 19, 2011 at 11:15pm

@iLoveGhoulia

I know, right? Ghoulia's my fave too, I was disappointed she was left out. But I'm hopeful she will be in the next one.

 

@Sunnie

Yeah, that actually makes more sense to me, that Mattel bought the rights to the characters from the book and not the other way around with them hiring Lisi to write about it and stuff. Personally, I prefer the storyline in the book. The webisodes are cute and everything, but I think the plot in the book is more interesting. Maybe it's just me though...

 

Anyway, I can't wait for the second book to come out. And even though everything doesn't line up exactly, I still feel like Melody deserves to be dolled. Perhaps Mattel will eventually decide the same.

• ‹ Previous
• 1
• 2
• Next ›
• Page